Why Choose a SAFe Note Over a Convertible Note

Why Choose a SAFe Note Over a Convertible Note?

For startups poised for growth, navigating the terrain of fundraising can be as crucial as the innovation that drives the business. Two popular instruments commonly used to facilitate early-stage financing are the Simple Agreement for Future Equity (SAFe) and convertible notes. While both options share the common goal of deferring the valuation of the company until a later date, they come with distinct features that can significantly influence a startup's financial and operational flexibility. In this article, we'll explore why a startup, especially those guided by firms like Punch Financial, might prefer a SAFe note over a convertible note.

Understanding the Basics

What is a SAFe Note?

A SAFe Note, or Simple Agreement for Future Equity, is a financial instrument used by startups and investors during early-stage funding rounds. The SAFe Note allows investors to provide capital to a startup in exchange for the right to receive equity at a later date, typically during a future-priced equity round. Unlike traditional equity investments, a SAFe Note does not immediately determine a valuation for the company; instead, it defers the valuation assessment to a future date when it's presumably easier to value the company more accurately.

What is a Convertible Note?

A convertible note is a financial instrument often used in early-stage startup financing. It is structured as a short-term loan that converts into equity, typically during a subsequent funding round. Convertible notes are used to bridge the gap between initial funding and larger, later-stage funding rounds, allowing startups to raise capital while delaying valuation.

Comparative Analysis: SAFe Note vs. Convertible Note

Valuation and Dilution:

·        SAFe Notes: SAFE notes, which do not accrue interest, convert the invested amount into equity based solely on the conditions like valuation caps or discounts set during the next equity financing round. This feature simplifies the investment and conversion process, as the amount of equity received by investors is calculated only from the principal amount. The valuation cap ensures that investors do not pay more than a predetermined amount per share, regardless of the startup's valuation at the time of conversion, and a discount offers shares at a reduced price compared to the latest round, thereby minimizing potential founder dilution.

·        Convertible Notes: Convertible notes accrue interest over time, which adds to the principal amount to be converted into equity, potentially complicating the conversion process and resulting in more significant dilution for the founders. Like SAFE notes, convertible notes may feature valuation caps and discounts, but the added interest means that the actual conversion involves more money, thus more shares being issued. The conversion terms are activated either at a subsequent funding round that meets specific criteria or at the note’s maturity date. The presence of accrued interest means the total cost for the company can be higher and less predictable, affecting both the company's financial planning and the equity structure post-conversion.

Complexity and Cost

·        SAFe Notes: Since SAFE notes do not accrue interest, there is no need to calculate interest payments or adjust the principal amount due over time, simplifying both the accounting and the legal documentation. Additionally, the terms of a SAFE note are typically less complex, focusing mainly on the valuation cap and discount, if any, without the additional layers of debt terms such as maturity dates and repayment clauses. This simplicity not only makes the administrative process less cumbersome but also reduces the legal costs associated with drafting and negotiating the terms of the agreement. The straightforward nature of SAFE notes can therefore lead to significant savings in both time and money for startups.

·        Convertible Notes: Convertible notes are structured as debt instruments and include more complex features like interest rates, maturity dates, and repayment obligations, which add layers of complexity to their management. The accrual of interest requires ongoing calculations to determine the exact amount that will convert into equity, and the presence of a maturity date necessitates additional strategic planning to manage potential repayments or conversions under less favorable conditions. These factors require more detailed financial management and more complex legal agreements to ensure all potential scenarios are covered, such as what happens if the note matures before a conversion event occurs. Consequently, the costs associated with drafting, negotiating, and managing convertible notes can be significantly higher, involving more extensive legal and financial advisory services. This complexity not only increases the costs but also extends the timeframe needed to finalize such agreements, potentially slowing down the funding process for startups.

Financial Impact

·        SAFe Notes: SAFE notes, being equity instruments, do not entail any debt or require repayment. This is particularly advantageous for startups, as it alleviates the burden of debt repayments, allowing them to utilize their limited cash resources for essential operations like product development, market expansion, and operational scalability. Furthermore, the absence of interest payments with SAFE notes simplifies financial planning, as startups do not need to account for accumulating interest, which could otherwise increase the financial burden and complicate future investment rounds by adding variables to the conversion calculations.

·        Convertible Notes: Convertible notes, on the other hand, introduce a layer of financial complexity due to their nature as debt instruments that accrue interest over time. This interest must ultimately be repaid, either in cash or by converting into additional equity at the time of conversion, which can significantly dilute existing equity holders, including the founders. The interest accrual increases the total amount of debt that converts into equity, potentially leading to a higher percentage of the company being given away than initially planned. This can have a substantial impact on the startup's valuation and the equity distribution among the founding team and early investors. Additionally, the presence of a maturity date on convertible notes can create financial pressure on a startup to secure another funding round or find other means to address this liability, potentially forcing them into unfavorable financial decisions merely to cover debt obligations.

Investor Appeal

·        SAFe Notes: SAFE notes are generally favored by investors who prioritize simplicity and speed in their transactions with startups. Since SAFE notes do not accrue interest and lack a maturity date, they offer a straightforward investment approach that focuses solely on equity conversion. This simplicity can be particularly appealing to investors who are confident in the startup's future success and prefer a clear, uncomplicated equity stake in the company. Additionally, the absence of a maturity date in SAFE notes removes the pressure of a looming financial obligation on the startup, potentially leading to a healthier long-term growth environment. Investors attracted to SAFE notes often value the ease of negotiations and the reduced legal overhead, seeing these instruments as a way to build a supportive relationship with the startup without the encumbrances of debt-like features.

·        Convertible Notes: While popular, they can sometimes be seen as less favorable due to their inherent debt-like nature, which introduces added financial pressure and complexity. The obligation to repay the principal with interest, unless converted into equity, can burden a young company's cash flow. Furthermore, the accrual of interest increases the total amount that is converted into equity, potentially resulting in greater dilution of existing shareholders than initially anticipated. This can be particularly concerning for founders who wish to retain more control over their company. Additionally, the presence of a maturity date forces companies to address the convertible note by a specific deadline, which may compel them to raise additional funding under less favorable conditions just to manage or avoid debt repayment. This combination of financial liability, potential for significant dilution, and the pressure of a ticking clock can make convertible notes a less attractive option for startups focused on growth and operational flexibility.

Timing and Flexibility

·        SAFe Notes: SAFE notes offer considerable flexibility as they do not come with a maturity date, freeing companies from the pressure to conduct a financing event or face repayment by a specific deadline. This absence of a maturity date allows startups to focus on growth and operational development without the looming financial pressures that can accompany timed debt instruments. Furthermore, SAFE notes typically convert during a priced equity round that meets predefined conditions, such as reaching a certain minimum investment amount. This setup aligns the conversion with natural growth milestones rather than arbitrary timelines, providing startups with the flexibility to plan and execute their growth strategies more effectively and organically.

·        Convertible Notes: convertible notes often include a maturity date, which can create significant timing pressures on a company. As this maturity date approaches, companies might find themselves forced to seek additional funding rounds not because it's the optimal strategic move for business growth but to avoid the financial implications of the note coming due. This can lead to suboptimal fundraising conditions and potentially unfavorable terms, as investors may leverage the company’s urgent need for funding to negotiate higher equity stakes or lower valuations. The accrual of interest on convertible notes further complicates this scenario by increasing the total amount that must be converted or repaid, potentially leading to greater dilution than initially planned. For these reasons, companies often favor SAFE notes for their simplicity and the operational leeway they afford, allowing founders to retain greater control over their financial strategy and company direction.

SAFe Note vs Convertible Note

Choosing between a SAFe note and a convertible note depends largely on the specific circumstances and strategic goals of the startup. For startups working with firms like Punch Financial, the emphasis on maintaining equity control, reducing complexity, and avoiding the burden of debt can make SAFe notes a particularly attractive option. They not only simplify the investment process but also align the interests of founders and investors toward mutual growth and success. By prioritizing these aspects, startups can position themselves effectively for future investment rounds and, ultimately, for sustainable, long-term growth.

If you're still curious or confused about potentially using a SAFe note for your capital raise, contact Punch Financial today to set up a meeting and get up to speed.


Join hundreds of small business owners who trust Punch

Let’s have a quick, no frills chat to discuss how we can help you.